Diluting English river standards a backward step, campaigners warn

Wildlife and countryside campaigners are urging the head of the Environment Agency not to weaken key rules which are driving the clean-up of rivers in England. Leading figures in the environmental sector have written to Sir James Bevan, chief executive of the EA, after a speech in which he suggested weakening the EU water framework directive now that the UK had left the union. To do so, the signatories to the letter say, would be a backward step. The signatories are calling for more investment so that English rivers meet the target of 75% rated good by 2027. Currently just 14% of rivers are judged as good under the directive.

In a recent speech to business leaders, Bevan called for “thoughtful reform” of the directive, which sets strong targets to clean up pollution in rivers and enhance the watercourses’ biodiversity. Bevan wants to abolish the “one-out-all-out” rule, which means rivers have to pass four stringent tests before being declared in good health. Instead he suggests that the directive be “reformed” to allow rivers to be judged on one criterion rather than all four, to deliver what he said would be “even better outcomes”.

Surfers Against Sewage have accused Bevan of trying to “rig” the system “to give false results” with his weakening of the directive. The surfers’ group signed the letter to Bevan on Friday, along with environmental NGOs including Wildlife and Countryside Link, the Angling Trust, the Wildlife Trusts, Woodland Trust, and RSPB.

The letter said Bevan should instead endorse a strengthening of the rules by introducing a long-term target in the environment bill for “clean waters” of the highest quality, which would include an inland bathing water standard to give the public confidence in the highest standards of water quality. The call for new inland bathing water standards chimes with the growing calls from river users who are demanding rivers clean enough to swim in. The letter to Bevan acknowledges that the pass or fail test within the EU directive does not enable regions to show where river quality has improved. But rather than axe the more stringent one-out-all-out rule it says the government should introduce a new metric for “elements improved” that shows the steps being made on the journey to achieving good quality overall.

Under the directive the British government is committed to a core target of achieving good status and a healthy water environment by 2027. This target should not be weakened, said the signatories.

Source: The Guardian 

Author: Saara Teirikko